Refugee Visa Australia Ask for help

Complementary protection for a protection visa: the significant harm test in s 36(2)(aa)

Complementary protection gives a protection visa to a person who is not a refugee but faces a real risk of significant harm, one of 5 kinds, if removed (s 36(2)(aa)). It is not a separate visa: you claim it in the same protection visa application. In your claims, describe every harm you fear, including harm not linked to the 5 refugee reasons.

Checked against government and legislation sources on 25 September 2026.

Ask for help Consult an Australian migration lawyer: your enquiry goes to Australian Migration Lawyers.

A large umbrella leaning open against a stone wall in light rain, dry ground beneath it.

Time limit. If your protection visa is refused on both criteria, apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal within 28 days of being notified, or 14 days if you were in immigration detention that day. The time cannot be extended (Migration Act s 347).

At a glance

Legal test
Migration Act 1958 s 36(2)(aa), Compilation No. 171 (4 June 2026)
Harms
5, listed in s 36(2A)
Standard
A real risk, on substantial grounds for believing
Visa
The same protection visa (866, 785 or 790): A$50 charge as at 1 July 2026; nil for a 785 or 790 applicant in detention who was not immigration cleared
Source obligations
Convention against Torture; ICCPR (Home Affairs, 23 September 2024)

What complementary protection is

Complementary protection is the second criterion for a protection visa, in s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act. It applies only to a person who is not found to be a refugee.

The Minister must have substantial grounds for believing there is a real risk of significant harm. That harm must be a necessary and foreseeable consequence of your removal to your country. The risk must be to you personally, not one faced by the population generally (s 36(2B)(c)).

The obligation comes from the Convention against Torture and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). Home Affairs explains that the Act writes these obligations into s 36(2)(aa) (23 September 2024).

A person granted on this ground gets the same visa and the same rights as a refugee who is granted. Section 36(2)(aa) is one of the sections of refugee law that decide a protection claim.

Is there a complementary protection visa?

No. A person owed complementary protection gets the same Protection visa (subclass 866), or a 785 or 790 if they arrived without a visa.

Where are the complementary protection guidelines?

The Administrative Review Tribunal’s Guide to refugee law in Australia, chapter 10, sets out how its members assess s 36(2)(aa).

The 5 types of significant harm

Significant harm is one of these 5 harms (s 36(2A)):

  1. Arbitrary deprivation of life. You would be killed without lawful reason.
  2. The death penalty. The death penalty would be carried out on you.
  3. Torture. Severe pain or suffering, physical or mental, intentionally inflicted to get information, punish, intimidate or coerce, or for discrimination (s 5(1)). Lawful sanctions consistent with the ICCPR are not torture.
  4. Cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment. Severe pain or suffering intentionally inflicted, or pain or suffering that is cruel or inhuman in nature (s 5(1)).
  5. Degrading treatment or punishment. An act or omission that causes, and is intended to cause, extreme humiliation that is unreasonable (s 5(1)).

Home Affairs says significant harm is different to the “serious harm” in the refugee test. It is a closed list of 5 harms, and economic hardship alone is not on it.

When there is no real risk (s 36(2B))

There is taken to be no real risk if the Minister is satisfied of any of these:

  1. relocating within the country is reasonable for you
  2. protection is available to you from an authority of the country
  3. the risk is faced by the population generally, not by you personally

Could you live safely in another part of your country?

If relocation is reasonable, there is no real risk. Explain why moving elsewhere in the country is not reasonable for you.

Could the authorities there protect you?

If an authority could protect you so that the real risk goes away, there is no real risk. Explain why the authorities cannot or will not protect you.

Is the risk the same for everyone there?

A risk shared by the whole population does not count. Explain why the risk is personal to you.

Who is excluded (s 36(2C))

A person does not meet the complementary protection criterion if there are:

  1. serious reasons to consider a crime against peace, a war crime or a crime against humanity
  2. serious reasons to consider a serious non-political crime before entering Australia
  3. serious reasons to consider acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations
  4. reasonable grounds to consider the person a danger to Australia’s security
  5. reasonable grounds to consider the person a danger to the community after a final conviction for a particularly serious crime, including a serious Australian or foreign offence

The refugee test has its own list of who is excluded from refugee status, in s 5H(2).

An excluded person is still protected from return to that country while a protection finding stands. Why that happens is explained under non-refoulement and complementary protection.

There is also no protection obligation if you have not used a right to live in a safe third country (s 36(3)).

Refugee or complementary protection: the difference

Refugee (s 36(2)(a))Complementary protection (s 36(2)(aa))
Why the harm happensOne of 5 Convention reasonsAny reason
StandardA real chance of persecutionA real risk, on substantial grounds for believing
HarmSerious harm, systematic and discriminatory1 of 5 significant harms
SourceThe Refugee ConventionThe Convention against Torture and the ICCPR
Order of assessmentConsidered firstConsidered only if not a refugee
Visa and rightsThe same for bothThe same for both
Exclusionss 5H(2) and s 36(1C)s 36(2C)

How it is claimed in a protection visa application

  1. Firstly, lodge one protection visa application in ImmiAccount (866, 785 or 790). There is no separate form.
  2. Secondly, describe every harm you fear in your claims, including harm not linked to the 5 refugee reasons. Under s 5AAA you must set out all the details and give enough evidence.
  3. Thirdly, show that the risk is to you personally, and why relocation or local protection would not work.
  4. Fourthly, the Department assesses refugee status first. It then records whether you meet s 36(2)(aa) under s 36A, before it considers any other criterion.
  5. Fifthly, attend the interview if you are asked. The Department provides an interpreter.
  6. Sixthly, receive the written decision. If you are refused, apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal within 28 days, or 14 days if you were in immigration detention that day.

A member of your family unit meets s 36(2)(c) by applying for the same class of visa you hold.

The protection visa and the statement of claims

The visa is the same protection visa Australia grants to refugees, so its eligibility, charge and bridging-visa rules apply to you. Because the claim stands on the harms you describe, the protection visa statement of claims guide shows how to set out each one.

A migration lawyer makes sure both criteria are argued, which makes a successful application more likely. No one can promise an outcome.

Common questions

Does complementary protection give permanent residence?
Yes, if you are granted a Protection visa (subclass 866), which is permanent from the day of grant. If you arrived without a visa, you get a 785 (3 years) or a 790 (5 years) instead.
Does general violence or war in my country count?
Not if the risk is faced by the population generally and not by you personally (s 36(2B)(c)). You must show a personal risk.
Is complementary protection considered if my refugee claim fails?
Yes. That is exactly when it applies: s 36(2)(aa) covers a person who is not a refugee.
Is the death penalty always significant harm?
Yes. A real risk that the death penalty will be carried out on you is one of the 5 harms (s 36(2A)(b)).

Sources checked for this page